Store small bath toys in suction cup shower baskets
Michelle's solution for bath toy storage:
I don't know if I'm the only one, but I find those mesh bags for bath toy storage really annoying. Yes, they let the toys drip dry, but the toys get all caught up in the netting (especially the smaller things, like the foam letters), making it a hassle to reach in and retrieve them before the next bath.
Instead, I got a couple of these plastic caddies that suction to the wall - they have holes in the bottom, so the water drains out nicely, and I put them at a height where it's easy enough for my boys to reach in and grab whatever toys they want themselves, and easy enough for them to put the toys away when they're done, too.
And a fun fact I discovered the other day, while cleaning the bathtub and simultaneously trying to keep my two boys (a 3-year-old and a 1-year-old) occupied - taking the bath toys OUT of the bathtub and playing with them on the floor makes them seem like brand-new toys!