13 February 2006

Choice words

Elana avoids meltdowns by avoiding yes-or-no questions:

One of the best things we learned was that kids shouldn't get questions that can be answered "yes" or "no."  Always give them a choice, and everyone ends up happy...they've decided for themselves, and you've avoided a massive meltdown that "no" can bring.

The wisdom of this advice appeals to me in theory, but I have what I like to call a "Choice C" kid. I give him a choice between A or B, and he suggests C, and we're back in throwing distance of a tantrum. When this happens, I change tactics and try to distract him.

"Honey, do you want milk or water with your lunch?"
"I want orange juice!"
"Yum! I just got a new batch of oranges! I'll cut some for you."
[Pause. Luke contemplates the oranges and forgets about the beverage choice. I silently pour him a glass of milk.]

Not always practical, but when it works, I've sidestepped at least 15 minutes of misery.

Technorati Tags: ,

Buy Minimalist Parenting today

If you like Parent Hacks, you'll love Asha's book (with co-author Christine Koh), Minimalist Parenting: Enjoy Modern Family Life More By Doing Less.

Buy it today at Amazon, Barnes & Noble, or your favorite local bookstore.

Want to get started now? Sign up for MinCamp, our free, 14-day companion workshop. Find out more

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bf6d653ef00d83473ea7d53ef

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Choice words:

Your comments

A similar strategy that I use with my son is to just "let him win" once in a while. Ask a question anticipating a "no."

So, near the end of the bedtime ritual, I ask "are you ready to lie down and go to sleep?" The answer is almost always "no," but that's fine. When it's really time for bed, I don't ask, and he goes peacefully to bed.

I got so tired of EVERYTHING being a choice (she'd not be able to decide, then tell me which one and then change her mind)... so I just started saying "do you want milk or no milk?" If she wants it, she gets it in the cup that I give her. She pulled a few tantrums about that but learned pretty quickly to just accept what I give her.

My personal favourite lately (new depths of parental despair), for putting on a shirt: Do you want to put your head in first or your hadns in first? Crazy toddlers. (and their crazy parents...)

We close comments after a month to guard against spam. Want to talk about this hack? Join us on Twitter and Facebook!

 

Get the Book

Free workshop

  • MinCamp is the free companion workshop to Minimalist Parenting. In 14 daily tasks, MinCamp jump-starts your progress toward less clutter in your schedule and home, relaxed mealtimes, and more time for yourself.

    Find out more and sign up now!

Start Amazon shopping here

  • Help support Parent Hacks with the shopping you're already doing!
    Do you buy diapers, gifts, or other items at Amazon? Every time, start your Amazon shopping by clicking this link (or any Amazon link at Parent Hacks).

    No matter what you buy, you'll be throwing some change into our tip jar without any extra steps or cost to you. Thank you!

Featured Posts

Elsewhere

The Accidental Expert

Read about my ONEMoms trip to Ethiopia in October 2012. Then become a member of ONE yourself! ONE will never ask for your money, only your voice. And one voice matters. I've seen it firsthand.